Bearing Witness

Besides furthering my education, the most important reason that I am spending a summer on the opposite side of the world from my home is to stand as a witness to the struggle of the Palestinian people. I have to say first that I have never met any people who, in general, are more resilient in the face of adversity, or have more mental fortitude and spiritual constitution than the Palestinian people.

Thinking about this brings to mind an interaction I had recently with Zoughbi’s 15 year old son Rafik.. We were talking about showering and I told him that I hoped our water was not cut off over the summer. (For those who don’t know, precious water is rationed to the Palestinians by the Israelis and it is common over the summer for the water to be cut off to Palestinian cities when it is in high demand in the surrounding Israeli settlements.) Rafik responded, “Oh, come on.. The water has to get cut off.. It’s part of the culture!” Now, most of you reading my blog are Americans, right? Think seriously, how would you react if someone told you getting your running water cut off during the hottest part of the summer was a “normal part of the culture”? Remember, you’re living in a desert climate, with scenery around you like you see in this picture… Just let that one sink in for a second…

Note: not all of Palestine looks like this. Some of it is rolling hills with olive tree terraces. Those black tanks you see are water tanks for Palestinians while the houses in the backgrounds are part of an Israeli settlement.

Despite the fact that there have been no terrorist attacks since 2008, the Israeli government continues to construct the Annexation Wall, which is already over 700 km long and cuts villages in half in some places. Here is a picture from the Wi’am Center (the place at which I work) showing their playground, which is overshadowed by a section of the Wall surrounding Rachel’s Tomb, a holy site that was once part of Bethlehem.

In the face of the wall, the Palestinians continue to persevere and hope for a better tomorrow.

Because I disagree with these kinds of conditions, I attended three demonstrations against the occupation last week.

Last Tuesday was a special occasion because it was Nakba Day, the day when Palestinians mourn the day their land begun to be annexed, or the Nakba (Arabic for ‘catastrophe’), while Israelis celebrate the day that their nation came into being. While protests in Ramallah escalated into clashes between Palestinian youth and Israeli troops, and 13 Arabs were killed attempting to enter Israel from Lebanon and Syria, the scene in Bethlehem was peaceful as crowds chanted “unity” and prayed for the end of the occupation.

I also attended more regular demonstrations last Friday. One of them was in a village called Ma’asara. The villagers hold a protest every Friday because the land that they have traditionally farmed has been designated for annexation by the Israeli government. There is not yet a wall or checkpoint there, but if they were to simply inhabit the land that was historically part of their village, Israeli soldiers would come to arrest them. Here, one of the villagers stands in front of the line of Israeli soldiers there to keep demonstrators from proceeding along the road.








I like this picture because it demonstrates the senselessness of the force deployed by Israel.. Are all these soldiers really necessary to disrupt a nonviolent demonstration by unarmed villagers?

The Israeli soldiers were taking pictures and video to document the faces of demonstrators, because any Palestinian who is involved in protests will automatically be denied a permit for access to Jerusalem. Hopefully the government will soon realize how nonviolent all of these protests are and how stupid it is to deploy troops against them..












The other demonstration on Friday was actually in the form of a Catholic Mass at a monastery outside of Bethlehem called Cremisan. As I noted above, there have been no terrorist attacks since 2008, yet the Israeli government continues construction of the Wall. That construction is set to destroy the land on which the Cremisan Monastery is founded, which the Palestinians rely on for olive trees. Every Friday, the monks from the Monastery lead a mass in protest.

Taking communion outside must be a refreshing change..

In the background you can see the settlement that this wall is designed to protect. I’m not 100% sure, but I would venture to guess that they have never experienced a single security threat from the direction of Cremisan.

Despite the conditions of adversity, the Palestinian people remain strong. Below is a picture that I think really exemplifies this from my trip last year when we visited the Tent of Nations. The ToN is a family farm surrounded by 4 Israeli settlements and besieged with legal attempts by the Israeli government to strip the family of their land for another settlement. The family has held out for years and isn’t going anywhere soon. Even though they waste thousands of dollars and hours per year defending their right to their own property (they have land deeds dating back to when the Ottoman Empire controlled the land), the sign at the entrance reads, “we refuse to be enemies.”

I don’t know what the other sign in Hebrew says, but I am told that it is the same message, with a more detailed description.

This is my biggest lesson so far. No matter the conditions of adversity, no matter how hard things are and how tempting it is to blame the “other” for your suffering, refuse to be their enemy, hold them in the Light in the tradition of Quakers, and hope for a better tomorrow.

In the meantime, take joy from things in life that are good, like kittens!

For more pictures, see my photobucket, which I am continuing to update:


About thichnhattim

Radically Moderate - neither right nor left brained, I try to use both. Student, activist, UU. Live life by the peaceful teachings of Thich Nhat Hanh. Redesign the flow, redefine the know, we're hanging on the ledge.
This entry was posted in Palestine/Israel Trip, Politics, Spirituality, Summer 2012 Bethlehem, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s